|
|
| TomTech
III - CFA, NETA Shear consept. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| NETA Shear is a technique
that turns any drilling machine into a geo-mechanical measurement
tool.
Throughout the history of CFA (Auger Cast) piles, there were attempts
to use drilling machines as a tool for pile performance and a geo-mechanical
measurement. In many cases, CFA (Auger Cast) piles are applied in
soft, weak, problematic soils. Due to the high-risk level and extreme
changes in the properties of soil within the limits of the same
site, the need aroused for an objective measurement tool to supply
information on the strength of soil surrounding the pile. |
|
Today, the most common technique is to monitor the
torque in the rotary system. The basic assumption is that there
is a direct, monotonous, relation between that torque and soil strength.
As the strength of soil increases - the torque in the rotary system
increases.
In reality, the torque of the rotary system is equally dependant
on the soil and driller activities. It is almost impossible to separate
between the two influences. Furthermore – there are kinds
of soils where the correlation between the torque and strength of
soil is reverse. It is problematic to use the toque of the rotary
system as a geo-mechanical criterion.
TOMER SYSTEMS BV. present a new concept
in using a drilling rig as a geomechanical tool – NETA
Shear. |
When inserting the auger into the soil in a rotary motion and by natural
penetration (similar to a theoretical screwing) the damage inflicted
on the soil is minimal. In other words, there is almost no disturbance
to the mass of the soil. If, after insertion to a depth of about 1
meter (3 foot), we brake the lifting cable so that it prevents the
auger from continuing to penetrate the soil, yet at the same time
continue rotating the auger, we obtain the array of forces as described
on drawing no. 17. |
|
The auger surface creates a compression force on the mass of
soil inside the auger.
The direction of this force is perpendicular to the auger surface.
We will name it the normal force. The magnitude of the normal force
depends on the shear strength of the soil only.
The normal force will increase until the soil is destructed (through
shear) then it will be completely canceled.
As customary in engineering, we will split the normal force into
two equivalent vectors – one horizontal and one vertical.
Clearly if the normal vector depends on the soil’s shear strength,
its components also depend on the soil’s shear strength. |
The point of applying the horizontal vector is far from the auger’s
axis of rotation therefore a moment around this axis is created.
This moment, along with all friction forces, are neutralized by
the torque of the rotary system.
The vertical force together with the proper weight of the rotary
system, the auger and the mass of soil, creates a vector on the
axis of rotation (due to symmetry) of the auger pointing downwards.
This vector is neutralized by the tension in the lifting cable.
By knowing the proper weight of the auger and rotary system and
the weight of soil inside the auger, we can easily calculate the
vertical component of the normal vector – the NETA
Shear. |
NETA Shear is very similar to Shear
Vane Test, but with twisted rips.
As stated before, the vertical component of the normal vector
depends solely on the shear strength of the soil. In other words
– by a simple measurement of the tension in the lifting cable
of the auger we can obtain a figure, which is equivalent to the
soil’s shear strength – NETA Shear.
In practice, the measurement process is carried out in 10 stages
(refer to drawing no. 18): |
|
|
1. We lay the auger on the soil, as
the lifting cable is loose. This measurement gives us the point of
the depth and zero load on the cable.
2. We lift the auger in the air and measure
the proper weight of the auger and rotary system.
3. We insert the auger into the ground
in a rotary motion, as the lifting cable is loose and let the auger
behave like a theoretical screw.
4. At the depth of approximately 1 meter
(3 foot), we brake the lifting cable and continue rotating the auger.
5. We measure the force developing in
the lifting cable in order to find the peak of tension. As the braking
of the lifting cable begins, the tension in the cable starts rising.
The tension force increases up to a maximum value (NETA
Shear) and then decreases. |
6. We continue rotating the auger in
order to find the minimum force allowed in the cable.
7. The maximum shear stress of the soil
equals the maximum tensile force developed minus the proper weight
measured at stage 2 above divided by the diameter of drilling divided
by the depth divided by 3.14 and multiplied by the pitch of the auger.
8. We continue inserting the auger as
a theoretical screw for an additional meter (3 foot) and repeat stages
3-6 above.
9. The maximum shear stress of the soil
equals the maximum tensile force measured minus the minimum force
measured on section 6 above divided by the depth of penetration at
this phase, divided by the diameter of pile divided by 3.14 and multiplied
by the pitch of the auger.
10. …and so on and so forth.
Note that:
1. Throughout the process, the auger
is rotating. All friction forces are in the horizontal plane and
distant from the axis of rotation therefore they turn into an horizontal
torque. This torque is neutralized by the rotary system only. The
friction forces, like the moments they create, have no influence
on the vertical vector or tensile force in the lifting cable (on
the NETA Shear). (refer to drawing
no. 6).
2. Most of the sections described in
the process of the NETA Shear measurement
are identical to those carried out in the MALI
Effect process (refer to chapter 2).
3. The required tension gauge in the
NETA Shear process is identical to
the one required in the MALI Effect
process.
4. As the auger structure is closer
to a theoretical screw – more accurate results will be obtained.
5. Due to the “screw” structure
of the auger, a large mechanical amplification is obtained in the
NETA Shear system (like the mechanical
mplification obtained in a worm). This amplification increases the
sensitivity of the system.
6. NETA Shear
represents the shear strength of the soil but is not necessarily
identical to this strength.
7. NETA Shear
is a sensitive, available, reliable and simple tool. It supplies
data at real time and enables more accurate control of the soil
properties – yet this is not an absolute tool and certainly
not a standard one.
8. Using the NETA
Shear must be done after careful consideration of the accuracy
of pitches in the auger, the shape of the bottom part of the auger
and the tool’s percentage of compression (compaction, displacement). |
Clearly, it is not intended that the operator will carry out a perfect
NETA Shear procedure on each pile.
This procedure should be carried out from time to time or once in
several piles.
Carrying out the full NETA Shear procedure
reduces the rate of work since the operator has to stop the penetration
each about 1 meter (3 foot) and rotate the auger for several seconds
in its place (increases the penetration time in few dozens of seconds
– approximately 10%).
Even in cases where the operator does not carry out a full accurate
NETA Shear procedure, due to the nature
of the auger penetration, the obtained results are a better reflection
of the shear strength of the soil than obtained by measuring the
torque in the rotary system.
|
|
|